Google+

Emitting Less by Working Less

As conversations around the nature of jobs and work evolve, we hear about an increasing number of alternatives and changes to the current system. A change that has gained popularity over the years is the switching over to a four-day workweek. Historically, our working hours have almost always been reducing due to increased worker productivity, and workers organizing to improve their material conditions. Since the end of the Industrial Revolution, where it was standard to work 60-70 hours per week, we have seen workers organizing to standardize the 10-hour workday, followed by the 8-hour workday and 48-hour work week, to the now standard (with notable exceptions) 5-day, 40-hour work week as of 1940. It stands to reason that we would have seen another reduction in our work hours since then, but that has not been the case.

There is growing evidence that a four-day workweek has many noteworthy benefits.Employees would certainly be eager to reduce their working hours if their wages remained the same. In fact, a trial conducted in 2022 showed a reduction in anxiety, fatigue, and sleep issues, as well as an improvement in work-life balance. Even sick days plummeted, showing a 65% reduction. This initial pilot was so successful that over 80% of firms involved said they wanted to continue with the shortened work week even after the trial ended. While it is obvious this policy would greatly benefit employees, it is worth noting the benefits the employers experience as well.

Similar trials across the United Kingdom, United States of America, and Japan have also shown a 22% increase in daily worker productivity, as well as a 37.5% increase in company revenues for firms involved in the trial. These reflect a net positive for the firms involved in these experiments. In addition, these companies also noted a reduction in some costs, such as Microsoft Japan noting a 23% reduction in electricity use and 60% reduction in paper printed. A few leaders at companies noted that because of the reduced working hours, employees were more judicious about their time and productivity, but also with them no longer racing out of the office, they were more cognizant of turning off their devices and appliances. The reduction in company product usage such as devices and office supplies leads to reduced wear-and-tear, and thus greater savings, and a reduced ecological impact due to less consumption.

This brings me to an often-overlooked aspect of worktime reduction: its environmental impact. A 2012 study by Juliet Schor calculated that a 10% reduction in work hours could reduce one’s carbon footprint by 8.6%, and a 25% reduction would lower it by 21.5%. Given this change is linear, we can calculate that a 20% reduction in work hours (the change from a 5-day to a 4-day workweek) would represent a 17.2% lower ecological footprint. Beyond the lowered consumption as previously mentioned, the biggest factor is the reduced travel for employees. With travel contributing to around 15% of global greenhouse gas emissions, this is a high-leverage area for emissions reduction. In fact, it was estimated that in the United Kingdom alone, a 4-day workweek would cut 558 million miles of driving per week. This, combined with other factors, adds up to the worktime reduction curbing emissions in the United Kingdom by 127 million tonnes annually.

While these numbers might sound incredibly ambitious, and the fact that they are estimates certainly leaves room for doubt, we can look to a real-world example to see how impactful these changes could actually be. When the city of Valencia, Spain experimented with a city-wide four-day workweek for one month, Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) concentration in the air went down by a staggering 58%. With this being achieved in one month alone, it lends credence to the calculations of how many tonnes of emissions could be curbed by a shorter workweek.

Another major environmental aspect of our work lives is the impact it has on data centres. As this is something we do not see, it is easy to overlook, but its impacts are colossal. Given that data centres use up the energy equivalent of thousands of homes, we must not ignore them. The 2022 four-day workweek trial in the UK has actually shown a significant drop in carbon emissions linked with the sending and storage of data. While the exact reason and the use of data was not tracked, this was suspected to be due to the drop from avoiding unnecessary internal communication and lowered business traffic on Fridays. Given the explosion in data use and transmission in recent years, it is likely that this itself would mean the ecological footprint reductions calculated by Schor in 2012 are massively underestimating what worktime reduction could do nearly a decade and half after these figures were first evaluated.

These calculations and statistics assume that a worktime reduction would result in lowered net emissions due to a massive lowering of emissions from work and related activities. However, there is still the possibility that worktime reduction would not curb net emissions, especially if people use their gained free time to partake in heavily emitting activities such as travel. Although, there is reason to believe that the overall impact would be positive as a study has shown that carbon emissions in North America and Europe are lower on weekends. While correlation is not causation, this heavily implies that our jobs themselves, paired with ancillary activities such as travel for the purpose of work, are responsible for these emissions.

When all of this data is taken together, it paints a fairly comprehensive picture of how beneficial a four-day workweek can be for the environment, for employee wellbeing, and for the employers as well. Society as a whole seems to benefit from it, and while there will certainly need to be adjustments to some occupations such as those employing hourly wage employees, the benefits are significant enough to warrant a discussion, if not a full-fledged implementation.

Alcuin Deverell Moras